Troy's Mom's




Troy's Cafe West Chester

4877 Smith Road

​Troy's Cafe Mason

322 Reading Road

Where to Buy

You can purchase a whole pie at any Troy's Cafe location.  Or call Troy to pre-order for a special event.  513-860-0573

​or email

The Original Peanut Butter Pie        $21.99 whole


The original Troy's Mom's Pie.  Made with a buttered Oreo crust, whipped natural peanut butter and cream with a dark decadent fudge and whipped cream topping.

The Best Key Lime Pie                     $21.99 whole


Straight from the Florida Keys, this recipe was brought to Ohio by Troy and him Mom.  Rich thick custard with a bite of key lime, almond and vanilla.  Setting on a crust of cinnamon gram crackers and topped with whipped cream.  This Key Lime Pie is the real deal.

Cookies and Cream                              $21.99 whole


A mixture of cream and Oreo cookies blended with the perfect amount of chunk still left.  Setting on a buttery Oreo crust and topped with velvety whipped cream and Oreo pieces.

​Caramel Delight                                 $21.99 whole


Trust me when I say that this pie is to die for.  Stiff caramel custard gently laid in a cinnamon gram cracker and salty pretzel crust.  Topped with a layer of sweet decadent caramel sauce and whipped cream, this pie is a mix of salty sweet bliss.